The Best Advice You Could Ever Get About Selecting Plays For Youth Theater
I’m a member of several Facebook groups for theater teachers. Other than enjoying reading their posts (which are hysterical sometimes), I am touched by their many questions and how they help each other. During this time of year teachers are looking for plays for young actors–youth theater plays to produce with their students or study in a class.
I can feel their frustration with selecting or even finding a script. Who better to receive advice from than those who has been in their shoes? That’s me. Here’s the best advice you could ever get about new plays for youth theater
We theater teachers are a different bunch. Selecting a play for students to read which appeals to most of them is a real challenge. A lot of theater teachers have students dropped on to their rosters who are not interested in theater and that’s another issue. Or a teacher finds a script but it’s juvenile or too mature. Or they lack merit, or quite frankly, they are just plain stupid. Plus, reading a play written for adults isn’t always the most appropriate for students. And…not everyone wants to read Shakespeare which seems to be a go-to when a teacher/director just can not think what else to do. That’s an entirely different blog post for another time.
My Background
Since I taught and directed for over thirty-eight years, I’ve had plenty of experience with this problem. If you want to see my employment resume, go to: Teaching Resume. When I began directing and teaching in the late 1980s, I couldn’t find plays for young actors. I’d pad scripts with extra characters to give students a line or two. Was it copyright infringement? Probably, but the play catalogues didn’t carry youth theater scripts at all. If I’m guilty of anything it’s guilty of trying to educate our youth. I rest my case!
The Best Advice You Could Ever Get About Selecting Plays For Youth Theater
Finally, out of sheer desperation, I co-developed a national playwriting contest for youth theater plays in 1988. You can read more about it here: Start a Playwriting Contest Using 20 Questions (part one) and Start a Playwriting Contest Using 20 Questions (part two).
It is my opinion that the youth theater play market became popular in the mid 1990s when Music Theater International unveiled its junior musical category. Suddenly, theater and vocal music teachers had musicals to perform instead of having to use full length musicals written primarily for adults. With the rise of MTI’s junior musicals popularity, playwrights could see a reason to create scripts for our youth. Now we have many playwrights writing for our youth.
Having taught and directed for all those years and experienced this issue firsthand, I have a good finger on the pulse of what our theater teachers need or require. I know what works and what doesn’t.
I’m so pleased with the number of people who read my blog each day keeping my little blog in the top 5 of the most popular in theater education. As I’ve mentioned before, I’m here to help.
What’s My Advice?
Although it may easiest just to produce a play you’ve directed in the past, my advice is to try a new playwright. Be daring and select something that is best for your students even if the community isn’t familiar with it. That’s the only way people can learn about–you be the first!
When we began our playwriting contest I mentioned above, we didn’t have many playwrights interested in participating. After several years, the word got out and many plays were entered in the contest. We’d bring the winner to Columbia, MO and they’d have an opportunity to see their new script performed by our theater school. It was a wonderful way for our community to experience new works and help the playwrights as well.
Consequently, I thought it would be useful to give some playwrights a platform in which to share their scripts. Here are several plays which I suggest you give a look and perhaps you will want to produce them:
The Losers’ Club
The Losers’ Club, published by Eldridge Publishing by Jonathan Turner Smith
One Act (High School Level)
Duration: 40 minutes
Cast: 8 m, 6 w
A group of outcast high sclhool students in a small Texas town have formed “The Losers’ Club.” On homecoming evening, these 12 students kidnap the star football player, Joe Taylor, and homecoming queen nominee, Tawny Harris, who have ignored, bullied, and ridiculed members of the club for years. Lead by Trenton, a 17-year-old Goth, the club members put the condescending Joe and Tawny on trial for “crimes committed against their fellow students.”
Each member of the “jury” details how he or she has been harassed by Joe, Tawny, and their friends, and how their lives have been affected by the abuse. What is revealed in the testimonies and the result of the trial is a surprise to all. An excellent play to serve as a catalyst for realistic discussions about bullying in schools across America.
Back to the 80s!
Back to the 80s! published by Playscripts.com publishing by Dean O’Carroll
Hold on to your hoverboards, we’re taking a trip Back to the 80s! When modern teen Mary Fitzfry gets sent back in time by an eccentric professor, she finds herself in the middle of a totally tubular cavalcade of 80s pop culture. There’s a lot of familiar faces, from the teens in breakfast-time detention to the guys chasing ghosts and dancing zombies, but the biggest surprise of all is Mary’s own protective mom as a teen. Turns out she’s actually kind of rad – but thanks to Mary’s time travel, she’s in trouble.
Can Mary make things right? This adventure takes you from the mall where everything happens, to a suburban sitcom street, to a cave under the high school – and you can choose who to feature from a flexible throng of characters to bring your audience maximum nostalgia. A hilarious parody to make all ages cheer “I love the 80s!”
The Best Advice You Could Ever Get About Selecting Plays For Youth Theater
The Kingdom of Academia
The Kingdom of Academia published by Brookly Publishers by Autumn Owens

It’s Her Say
Type: Drama/Comedy (Middle School and up)
Short Play Collection.
Durations: Each play is 10-20 minutes.
Speaking Cast: 10-20 actors, flexible casting
It’s Her Say, a collection of short plays that focus on the female experience, can be used in the classroom for scene study or licensed for production. Ranging from historical fictionto social consciousness to shifting friendships to horror comedy, each play is written by a female-identifying theatre teacher who knows exactly what young performers are capable of and what kind of work they are eager to perform. This collection includes the following short plays:
Some Things Never Changeby Jane Best
I Said Run.by Rachel Bublitz
The Women’s Land Armyby Stephanie Buckley
Beauty Kweenzby Diana Burbano
Talk to Me About Homeby Eugenie Carabatsos
The Bootby Emily Hageman
Angela and Angie and Cynthiaby Patty MacMullen
The Stakeout by K. Alexa Mavromatis
The Un-Help Desk by Emily McClain
Girl, Period by Stephanie Shearer
(These plays can be licensed together or separately. If you license the whole collection, you have permission to pick and choose which plays to perform.)
I hope you take my advice and check out these plays in the near future. This has been such a successful experience that I plan to blog again about this subject suggesting other plays suitable for our students! Make sure you are following me so you’ll know when I’ve blogged again. Join here:
What is one of your favorite youth theater plays? I’d love to discuss it with you. Contact me at DhcBaldwin@gmail.com